As a Six Sigma Expert, I have experienced, guided and sometimes caused quite a few change processes myself. New processes, different responsibilities, reorganizations, cost savings, international changes. On paper it all worked out perfectly. The business case had been calculated, the process was more logical and the planning was clear. And then it turned out that people were also involved.
The latter sounds lame, but it goes wrong surprisingly often. We think that change will follow once we have explained well enough why the new is better. Add a presentation, plan on the screen, divide tasks and move forward. However, a person does not work like a process diagram in which you change something on the left and the desired behavior automatically appears on the right.
That is why, in my opinion, the book Switch – dare to change by Chip and Dan Heath should have been written earlier. The gist is simple: if you want something to change, eventually someone somewhere has to act differently. To achieve this, according to the authors, you need to bring three things: the rational Rider, the emotional Elephant and the Path on which they must move together. Years later, I still find that image useful.
Change can be rationally correct and yet humanly derailing
My own experiences with change are not only positive. In June 2011, my team and I were unpleasantly surprised by a decision that suddenly made us part of the change. No more beautiful change strategy from the sidelines; we were in the middle of it.
Later I gave training at a multinational in Switzerland that was undergoing a reorganization. During the first training there were nine people in the room. Two months later there were still four. Some of the others had now been discharged and were home sick. You don't just forget that.
Not because organizations are never allowed to reorganize or say goodbye to people. Sometimes that's necessary. But the way you organize change matters. It is precisely when uncertainty is great that communication becomes more important. People don't just listen to what you say. They also pay attention to what you do, what you omit, who gets information, when decisions are made and whether reality matches the words with which the change process once began. So you can make an excellent decision from a commercial perspective and at the same time lose a lot of confidence.

The Rider wants to know where to go
In Switch, the Rider represents our rational side. He wants to understand what needs to change and why. The Heath brothers advise, among other things, to look at what already works, make the desired behavior concrete and clearly show where you want to go.
That sounds simple, but organizations are remarkably good at abstract change words. We are going to “transform”, “accelerate”, “create more ownership” or “put the customer more centrally”. Everyone nods and then walks back to their desks asking what they should do differently tomorrow. I recognize Vision and Structure in that. Vision gives meaning: why are we doing this and where do we want to go? Structure translates that into reality. What specifically changes? What remains the same? Who decides? Which step comes first? And what does this mean for my work?
As long as people don't have an answer to that, resistance is sometimes just a lack of information in a more emotional package.
The Elephant has little interest in your PowerPoint
Then there is the Elephant: our emotional side. You can rationally fully understand why change is necessary and yet not be at all ready for it. I think that is perhaps the most underestimated part of change communication. Management has often thought about a change for months before announcing it. Scenarios have been discussed, calculations made, objections weighed. When the decision is finally presented, management is much further along in the processing process. The employee hears it for the first time that morning and perhaps twenty minutes later is asked whether he can “go along with the new direction”. That's quite something.
Trust cannot be accelerated because the project plan will turn out differently. People sometimes first want to understand what a change means for their position, relationships, security or professional identity. That does not mean that every emotion needs to be discussed endlessly. It does mean that you cannot expect someone to agree rationally and immediately be in the same place emotionally.
And sometimes it's just the Path
I think the third element of Switch is at least as important: make the desired behavior easier. The Heath brothers call that smoothing the path. Adjust the environment, develop habits and ensure that new behavior can spread.
Because sometimes we call for behavioral change while the organization still facilitates the old behavior excellently. We want more collaboration, but judge people solely on individual results. We also want ownership, but every decision has to go through three management layers. Meanwhile, employees must help customers faster, while the system requires six approvals. We then send everyone to a training course on proactivity. Then the problem may not lie between the employee's ears.
That's where Action comes into the picture. People must be able to actually act. If the new behavior is structurally more difficult than the old one, the old one surprisingly often wins.
Resistance is information
That is also why I no longer think the original title Overcoming Obstacles in Change Processes fits. The word overcome suggests that resistance is primarily something that must be avoided. I don't believe in that anymore.
Resistance can be difficult, but it can also contain extremely valuable information. The Vision may be incorrect. Perhaps Trust is lacking. Sometimes the Structure appears unclear. Perhaps the system is preventing the desired Action. And sometimes people are right when they say a change doesn't work.
Good leadership does not mean that you have to convince them more effectively. It means listening keenly enough to hear the difference between fear of change and a valid objection to a bad plan.
Change ultimately starts with behavior
The sentence from Switch that stuck with me is essentially very simple: if something has to change, someone somewhere has to do something different. This requires a good plan, but also meaning, trust, clarity and space to actually act. Or, in the language of the Connective Code: Vision, Trust, Structure and Action. When these four reinforce each other, change does not have to be pushed as hard. People understand better why something happens, can relate to it, know what is expected of them and are given the opportunity to take action themselves.
And even when the outcome is painful, such as a reorganization or farewell, you can still treat people with clarity and respect. Perhaps that is the real test of change leadership.
Are you encountering three concrete changes where people seem to understand what the intention is, but the movement does not materialize? Include them in an introductory meeting. Together we look at where Vision, Trust, Structure or Action is lacking and what that means for the way you communicate and decide.
Would you first like to discover which language you naturally speak most easily and which needs you may therefore less naturally take into account during change? Take the Code Quiz.