← Back to the knowledge base

Knowledge base · Verbindend Zakendoen

Why customers decide differently than you think

Years ago I saw a woman posing on the hood of a car to make the car more attractive. My first thought was something like: can't be true. What on earth does that woman have to do with the engine performance, fuel economy or quality of that car? Quite little, as it turned out when I thought about it more. But she had everything to do with attention.

Years ago I saw a woman posing on the hood of a car to make the car more attractive. My first thought was something like: can't be true. What on earth does that woman have to do with the engine performance, fuel economy or quality of that car? Quite little, as it turned out when I thought about it more. But she had everything to do with attention.

The same thing happens when a chocolate bar appears on screen so big and shiny that you can almost smell it, when an insurer first shows in detail what can go wrong or when a hotel website tells you that there is “only one room available”. We like to think that we make our purchasing decisions mainly rationally. In reality, attention, emotion, expectations, trust and convenience come into play long before we have drawn up a neat list of arguments.

That makes psychology so interesting to me in sales and marketing. Not because you can manipulate customers more intelligently, but because you can better understand what someone needs in order to make a decision in the first place.

Image accompanying Why customers decide differently than you think

We don't make decisions with one neat, rational brain

In the old version of this article I wrote about an old, middle and new brain. That model was popular for years, but reality is much less neatly divided into three floors. However, psychologists still make a distinction between processes that run relatively quickly and automatically and processes in which we weigh and reason more consciously. These processes constantly interact with each other.

You probably recognize that without a brain scan. You walk into a store and immediately find something beautiful. Only then do you think why. You meet someone and within seconds you feel a sense of trust or reluctance, while your rational file is still almost empty. You see an offer and first think “interesting” and then collect arguments that support or correct that feeling.

This means that feeling is not stupid and reason is not superior. We need both. The problem starts when a company only talks to the rational part of the customer while that customer elsewhere has long since dropped out.

Trust sometimes begins before someone has read a single word

You can see that online, for example. Research by Elizabeth Sillence and colleagues into health websites showed that people quickly assess websites in the initial phase and sometimes even reject good information due to poor design. Only when a website passes that first quick selection will content, credibility and personal relevance become more important. I find that extremely relevant commercially.

You can be the best specialist in your field in terms of content and still lose customers because your website looks chaotic, the navigation is not logical, your offer remains vague or the visitor does not understand where to start. Conversely, a beautiful design ultimately won't save you if the content is incorrect.

So a customer constantly assesses two things: can I trust this and do I understand what is relevant to me here?

That is why I find “the content is the most important” just as incomplete as “it is mainly about appearance”. Good communication needs both.

Words do more than convey information

Language also influences how we perceive something. A classic experiment by Elizabeth Loftus and John Palmer showed participants images of car accidents. Just the verb used to ask about the collision later affected how fast participants thought the cars had been traveling.

That doesn't mean that you can make every customer believe anything with a few clever words. Good thing, too. It does show that word choice is not neutral.

There is a difference between: “Why haven't you made a decision yet?” and: “What else do you need to make a good decision?” The first sentence can create pressure. The second opens investigation.

Words such as costs, investment, risk, possibility, obligation and choice also evoke different expectations. That's why I think words are so important. Not to bypass the customer's mind, but because careful use of language helps to speak about the same thing more precisely.

More choice does not automatically mean better service

Another interesting phenomenon: choice. It's easy for us to think that more options are more customer-friendly. If three options are nice, twelve options will be great. Research into choice overload shows a more nuanced picture. Too much choice can make decision-making more difficult, especially when the options are complicated, the customer does not yet know what he wants or the decision requires a lot of effort. But more choice is not a bad thing under all circumstances; the context determines a lot. That's why I wouldn't automatically show everything you can do on a website.

A potential customer does not need to be handed your entire warehouse, intellectual toolbox and professional life's work on one page. He first wants an answer to a simpler question: is this for me? Only then does the next choice come.

That is not a simplification of your customer. It is respect for the amount of information someone has to process at the same time.

This is where the Connective Code comes together for me

Psychology therefore shows that people do not make decisions solely based on facts. They pay attention to meaning, trust, clarity, feeling, risk, convenience and the opportunity to take the next step.

I recognize the four needs of the Connective Code in that. Vision wants to understand why something is relevant and where it leads. Trust seeks credibility, relationship and the feeling that words and reality fit together. Structure wants to be able to oversee how something works, what it costs and what happens after a YES. Action does not want to get lost in information but wants to know what the next step is.

Not every customer needs the same amount of all four at all times. This is precisely where communication often goes wrong. An entrepreneur provides even more proof while the customer actually feels insufficient trust. A website tells a beautiful story but does not show what the process is. A salesperson discusses every possible option, while the customer would mainly be helped by two clear choices.

And sometimes there is so much explanation that someone who has long wanted to say YES is now having doubts again.

Good influencing gives someone more control, not less

For me, that is now the line between influencing and manipulating. Of course marketing wants to influence behavior. Otherwise you don't have to make fun of her. But I find it more interesting when psychology is used to help a customer decide better instead of faster.

Does anyone understand what you are offering? Are the pros and cons clear? Can a customer judge whether something suits him? Is there enough trust? Aren't there many unnecessary obstacles built in? And is NO really allowed? If the answer to that is YES, then you don't need to use psychology as a bag of tricks. Then it becomes a way to communicate better.

Where does your customer drop out?

Perhaps your offer is excellent in terms of content and the doubt arises elsewhere: in the words, the design, the amount of choice, the process or the trust that your communication evokes.

Include your three most important challenges in your website, customer journey or commercial communication in an introductory meeting. Together we look at where customers may unintentionally drop out and whether Vision, Trust, Structure or Action are lacking.

Would you first like to discover which communication language you naturally speak most easily and which needs you may therefore address less naturally? Then take the Connective Code Quiz.